Weekend Deals are live!
Log in Sign up
Cart (0) Check Out

New Secondhand Arrivals

Back to all new arrivals, including products new to our store.
1998 GiGi the Black Poodle Plush - TY Beanie Babies
1998 GiGi the Black Poodle Plush - TY Beanie Babies
$12.00 — LAST ONE!
1999 Signature Bear Plush - TY Beanie Babies
1999 Signature Bear Plush - TY Beanie Babies
$12.00 — LAST ONE!
1998 Clubby the Teddy Bear Plush - TY Beanie Babies - BBOC Exclusive
1998 Clubby the Teddy Bear Plush - TY Beanie Babies - BBOC Exclusive
$12.00 — LAST ONE!
1998 Erin the Bear Plush - St. Patrick's Day - TY Beanie Babies
1998 Erin the Bear Plush - St. Patrick's Day - TY Beanie Babies
$15.00
1999 Osito the Bear Mexican Flag Plush - TY Beanie Babies - USA Exclusive
1999 Osito the Bear Mexican Flag Plush - TY Beanie Babies - USA Exclusive
$12.00 — LAST ONE!
1999 Kicks the Bear Soccer Plush - TY Beanie Babies
1999 Kicks the Bear Soccer Plush - TY Beanie Babies
$12.00 — LAST ONE!
2000 USA the Bear Plush - TY Beanie Babies - USA Exclusive
2000 USA the Bear Plush - TY Beanie Babies - USA Exclusive
$8.00 — LAST ONE!
2001 Romance the Bear Plush - Valentine's Day - TY Beanie Babies
2001 Romance the Bear Plush - Valentine's Day - TY Beanie Babies
$12.00 — LAST ONE!
2001 Holiday Teddy Bear Plush - TY Beanie Babies Christmas
2001 Holiday Teddy Bear Plush - TY Beanie Babies Christmas
$10.00 — LAST ONE!
2001 Cheery the Bear Plush - TY Beanie Babies
2001 Cheery the Bear Plush - TY Beanie Babies
$15.00
2004 Dear the Pink Bear Plush - TY Beanie Babies - Hallmark Exclusive
2004 Dear the Pink Bear Plush - TY Beanie Babies - Hallmark Exclusive
$15.00 — LAST ONE!
2005 Illinois Violet Bear Plush - State Exclusive Series - TY Beanie Babies
2005 Illinois Violet Bear Plush - State Exclusive Series - TY Beanie Babies
$15.00 — LAST ONE!
Copyright © 2025, Mary Bear
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Venmo
  • Visa